Physics Tutorial: Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision

[ 1 Votes ]

In this Physics tutorial, you will learn:

  • What is impulse?
  • How impulse is related to momentum?
  • When does the phenomenon of impulse take place?
  • How can we represent the impulse graphically?
  • What is the definition of collision?
  • How many types of collision arte there?
  • What occurs during each type of collision?

Introduction

Suppose you throw two identical stones from the same height. Obviously, they hit the ground at the same velocity. The first stone falls on a hard ground while the other on a kind of sponge. Both stones stop moving after their respective collision.

Do you think both stones experience the same change in momentum? Why?

Which stone causes more harm on the surface they hit? Why?

Which stone do you think is more damaged after the collision? Why?

The Meaning of Impulse

Let's try to answer the above questions. Thus, apparently, it looks like both objects have experienced the same change in momentum, as since both of them fall down from the same height, their velocity near the ground is equal. On the other hand, they have a zero momentum after the collision, as both of them stop moving after hitting the ground.

However, it is obvious the balls have experienced different processes during their contacts with the respective surfaces. The collision of the first ball (the one that falls on a hard ground) causes a greater impact on both the ball and the ground as they may be easily damaged. On the other hand, the collision with the sponge does not cause any harm in any of the objects in contact as it is "amortized" i.e. absorbed by sponge's softness. Hence, the collision is slower and more extended in time compared to the first case due to the elastic properties of sponge. Look at the figure:

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision

But what can we say about the collision force? Is it the same in both cases?

To answer this question, let's transform the equation of the change in momentum we obtained in the previous tutorial, "Linear Momentum". We have:

Equation 1

∆p = p1 - p2
= m × v1 - m × v2
= m × ∆v

If we divide both sides of the above equation by the collision interval Δt, we obtain

p/∆t = m × ∆v/∆t

From Kinematics, we know that

v/∆t = a

where a is the acceleration of the object. Therefore, we obtain after substitutions

Equation 2

p/∆t = m × a

The right side of the equation (2) represents the right side of the Newton's Second Law of Motion,

Equation 3

F = m × a

where F is the force of collision. Therefore, combining the left sides of equations (2) and (3), we obtain

Equation 4

F = p/∆t

The equation (4) therefore represents another way of writing the Newton's Second Law of Motion. If we transform the equation (4) into

Equation 5

J = ∆p = F × ∆t

we obtain a new concept known as "Impulse" which represents the relationship between the change in momentum, collision force and time interval during which the collision occurs. Impulse is denoted by J and it is a vector quantity as it is obtained by subtracting two vectors. Therefore, an object has an impulse only during the collision while before and after the collision it has only momentums. The following table clarifies this point:

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision

Impulse as a change in momentum has the same unit as momentum, i.e. kg × m / s. In many textbooks, the concept of force is not expressed in its traditional form, i.e. Force = Mass ×; Acceleration based on Newton's Second Law of Motion, but is the form of equation (4), i.e. in terms of impulse and the collision interval.

Now, let's return to the question regarding the collision force, i.e. whether it is the same in both cases mentioned above or not. When the object falls on hard ground, it jumps immediately after the impact, although this jump may be very small to be noticeable for our eyes. This means the impact interval is very short and therefore, the force is big. On the other hand, when the object falls on a soft surface such as a sponge, it takes a much longer to it pushing the surface and reach the bottom. Therefore, as force and collision interval are inversely proportional to each other, the impact force when the object falls on a soft ground is much smaller than when the same object falls on hard ground.

Example 1

A 50 g steel ball hits a metal surface at 12 m/s and bounces back at 8 m/s. the ball is in contact with the metal surface for 0.02 s as shown in the figure.

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision

What is the force of collision between the steel ball and the metal surface?

Solution 1

The ball changes direction after the collision, so we must take its final velocity as negative. As for the other clues, we must not forget to convert the mass of the ball from 50 g into 0.05 kg.

Given the relationship between the change in momentum and impulse, we have

F × ∆t = m × v1 - m × v2

Substituting the known values, we obtain

F × 0.02 = 0.05 × 12-0.05 × (-8)
F × 0.02 = 0.6 + 0.4
F × 0.02 = 1
F = 1/0.02 = 50 N

The direction of force depends on what we are concerned for. If we want to know the force by which the ball hits the metal surface, it is easy to find that in the specific case, it is due right. On the other hand, the force by which the metal reacts to the ball is 50 N as well but due left, based on the action-reaction principle.

Types of Collision

First, let's explain what is collision, because we have mentioned this term many times in the last two articles without giving its definition.

In physics, Collision, also called impact, represents the sudden, forceful coming together in direct contact of two bodies, such as, for example, two balls, a hammer and a nail head, or a falling object and a floor.

There are two main types of collision. They are:

  1. Elastic collision in which objects move apart after the contact, and
  2. Inelastic collision in which objects move together after the collision.

In all examples discussed in the last two articles, we considered only elastic collisions in which one of the objects in contact was unmoveable (wall, metal surface, thin sheet, etc.) while the other (usually a ball or a stone) was moveable and approached the unmoveable object and eventually hit it. Then, the objects moved apart.

The highest stage of elastic collision is when an object moves at the same speed (not velocity) after the impact. This means it conserves the kinetic energy and therefore, no energy turns into other forms such as heat, sound, light (in sparks), etc. Such collision is called "absolutely (completely) elastic collision" and obviously, this is an idealization because it is clear that it is impossible not hearing any noise or not producing any heat during an impact. For example, when you hit a nail using a hammer, the nail head will become hot after a number of hits. This means some of hammer's initial kinetic energy converts into heat during the process. You hear a loud noise as well, so some kinetic energy of the hammer converts into sound. Finally, you can see some sparks at the nail's head. This means some of the initial kinetic energy of hammer converts into light energy, and so on.

However, for convenience we will consider perfectly elastic collisions in some of the future exercise. This means we will neglect the other energy conversions that take place during the process.

Example 2

A 400 g ball falls from 6 m above the ground and rises up to 3.6 m after the impact with the ground. The collision lasts for 0.05 s. Ignore air resistance and take g = 10 m/s2 for convenience.

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision
  1. What kind of collision is this?
  2. What is the force of impact with the ground?

Solution 2

a. It is obvious this collision is elastic as the ball moves away from the ground after the impact. Thus, we have to determine whether the collision is absolutely (completely) elastic or not. We can find this by working out the velocities before and after the impact to the ground. If these velocities (despite they may have opposite direction) have the same magnitude, the collision is absolutely (completely) elastic, otherwise it is not. At this point, we can use the energetic approach to determine the velocity of the ball just before touching the ground, which we will consider as the initial velocity v1 before the impact, and the velocity of the ball immediately after leaving the ground, which we consider as the final velocity v2.

When the object is initially at 6 m above the ground (at the instant zero), it possesses only gravitational potential energy, which is converted into kinetic energy at the instant just before the object touches the ground (instant 1). Thus, we have

GPE0 = KE1
m × g × h0 = m × v21/2

Simplifying the mass from both sides and substituting the known values, we obtain for the velocity of the ball just before striking the ground:

10 × 6 = v21/2
v21 = 10 × 6 × 2 = 120
v1 = √120 ≈ 11.0 m/s downwards

To determine the value of the ball's velocity just after leaving the ground, we must keep in mind that the kinetic energy of the ball just when it leaves the ground is equal to the final gravitational potential energy at h3 = 3.6 m. Therefore, we have

KE2 = GPE3
m × v22/2 = m × g × h3

Again, simplifying mass from both sides and substituting the known values, we obtain for the velocity of the ball just immediately after leaving the ground:

v22/2= 10 × 3.6
v22 = 2 × 10 × 3.6 = 72
v2 = √72 ≈ 8.5 m/s upwards

Since the magnitudes of velocity are not equal, this is an elastic collision but not absolutely (completely) elastic.

b. The force of impact to the ground is determined by calculating the impulse. Thus, taking the velocity before the impact as positive and that after the impact as negative (and given that m = 400 g = 0.4 kg), we write

F × ∆t = m × v1 - m × v2
F × 0.05 = 0.4 × 11.0 - 0.4 × (-8.5)
F × 0.05 = 4.4 + 3.4 = 7.8
F = 7.8/0.05 = 156 N

Graphical Representation of Impulse

Since in impulse the impact interval usually is very short, we take the impact force as uniform. Therefore, in the simplified version, impulse is represented by the area under the Force vs Time graph involved. Look at the figure below.

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision

In this case, we have F = 20 N and Δt = 0.2 s - 0.1 s = 0.1 s. Hence,

J = F × ∆t = 20 N × 0.1 s = 2 kg × m/s

What can we say about impulse in inelastic collisions?

If the collision time interval is prolonged, we cannot speak anymore for impulse, as impulse takes place only when a force is exerted in a very short time interval on an object. Therefore, we cannot discuss about impulse in inelastic collision because in such collisions, the objects stick together after the impact and as a result, the impact time practically extends at infinity if no other force in the opposite direction is exerted to detach them.

Summary

In physics, Collision, also called impact, represents the sudden, forceful coming together in direct contact of two bodies, such as, for example, two balls, a hammer and a nail head, or a falling object and a floor.

There are two main types of collision. They are:

  1. Elastic collision in which objects move apart after the contact, and
  2. 2- Inelastic collision in which objects move together after the collision.

The highest stage of elastic collision is when an object moves at the same speed (not velocity) after the impact. This means it conserves the kinetic energy and therefore, no energy turns into other forms such as heat, sound, light (in sparks), etc. Such collision is called "absolutely (completely) elastic collision" and obviously, this is an idealization because it is clear that it is impossible not hearing any noise or not producing any heat during an impact.

"Impulse" represents the relationship between the change in momentum, collision force and time interval during which the collision occurs. Impulse is a vector quantity. It is denoted by J and it is measured by the same unit as momentum [kg × m / s], as it is obtained by subtracting the initial and final momentum of an object.

Mathematically, we have:

J = ∆p = F × ∆t
= m × ∆v
= m × v1 - m × v2

We can speak for impulse only during the collision; neither before, nor after it.

Newton's Second Law of Motion is often expressed in terms of impulse and time interval, i.e. as

F = J/∆t = p/∆t

Since in impulse the impact interval usually is very short, we take the impact force as uniform. Therefore, in the simplified version, impulse is represented by the area under the Force vs Time graph involved.

If the collision time interval is prolonged, we cannot speak anymore for impulse, as impulse takes place only when a force is exerted in a very short time interval on an object. Therefore, we cannot discuss about impulse in inelastic collision because in such collisions, the objects stick together after the impact and as a result, the impact time practically extends at infinity if no other force in the opposite direction is exerted to detach them.

Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision Revision Questions

1) A 40 g bullet hits a 20 cm thick wooden trunk at 200 m/s. The bullet decelerates due to the friction and leaves the trunk in the opposite side at 100 m/s. Calculate the average force exerted by the bullet in the trunk.

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision
  1. 300 N
  2. 3000 N
  3. 30 000 N
  4. 300 000 N

Correct Answer: B

2) A 3 kg object hits a hard surface at 6 m/s and then turns back. The collision lasts for 0.1 s and the force of impact is 360 N. What type of collision is it?

  1. Completely elastic
  2. Elastic but not completely
  3. Inelastic but nut completely
  4. Completely inelastic

Correct Answer: A

3) A 2 kg object hits a hard surface at 20 m/s due North. The Force vs Time graph for this object is shown in the figure below.

Physics Tutorials: This image provides visual information for the physics tutorial Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision What is the velocity of the object after the collision?
  1. 35 m/s due North
  2. 15 m/s due South
  3. 70 m/s due South
  4. 35 m/s due South

Correct Answer: B

We hope you found this Physics tutorial "Collision and Impulse. Types of Collision" useful. If you thought the guide useful, it would be great if you could spare the time to rate this tutorial and/or share on social media, this helps us identify popular tutorials and calculators and expand our free learning resources to support our users around the world have free access to expand their knowledge of physics and other disciplines. In our next tutorial, we expand your insight and knowledge of "Collision And Impulse" with our Physics tutorial on Law of Conservation of Momentum and Kinetic Energy.

Related Physics Calculators by iCalculator

    Physics Calculators

    You may also find the following Physics calculators useful.